Dusty, D'Arcy Street and a Delicious Political Irony

18 November 2026

I had genuinely decided to let sleeping dogs lie.

After years of arguments, submissions, petitions, consultations and political manoeuvring over dogs at South Hobart Oval, the issue was finally settled.

Time to move on. Find something else to get worked up about.

But sometimes life hands you something so bloody good that you simply can't resist.

And like a dog with a bone, I wasn't about to let this one go.

My phone started buzzing.

The text messages were flying.

"You couldn't make this up!"

"OMG, the irony!"

"Can you BELIEVE this?"

I must confess, I was laughing.

Quite a lot, actually.

Because sometimes satire writes itself.

And sometimes it arrives at Hobart City Council on four legs, answers to the name Dusty, and manages to achieve in one evening what years of council meetings and public consultation couldn't.

And who should find himself uncomfortable with a dog wandering around his workplace?

Councillor Mike Dutta.

Yes. That Mike Dutta.

The councillor who voted against restricting dogs from South Hobart Oval.

You really do have to admire Dusty's timing.

Enter Dusty

Hobart's newly elected Lord Mayor, Charles Wooley, is clearly fond of his dog.

And why wouldn't he be?

But towards the end of Monday night's council meeting, his very first in the chair, Dusty apparently decided to make his own contribution to proceedings.

Unfortunately, his chosen audience was Councillor Mike Dutta.

"Excuse me. I have a bit of a problem with dogs," he told the meeting.

"Because I was bitten once and I feel very uncomfortable."

Fair enough.

The Lord Mayor attempted to retrieve Dusty, who appeared to have developed an independent position on the matter.

After several calls, order was restored.

Wooley assured everyone Dusty was under control.

He later explained that Dusty wasn't on a leash because he "doesn't need to be on a leash".

Of course he doesn't.

They never do.

Until they do.

Ah, D'Arcy Street. Remember That?

For those who missed Hobart's longest-running canine soap opera, South Hobart Oval has been the subject of years of argument over whether dogs should be permitted on the playing surface.

A football ground.

Not a dog park that happens to have goalposts.

The football community raised concerns about dog waste, digging, damage and the safety of people using the ground.

Dog owners argued that it was a community space and should be shared.

Eventually, Hobart City Council voted seven to five to restrict dogs from the oval.

It took years to get there.

Dusty managed to revisit the central argument in approximately one council meeting.

Without even being on the agenda.

Six Kids, a Football and a Very Friendly Dog

Imagine six children enjoying themselves on South Hobart Oval under the old shared-use arrangements.

Perhaps they're kicking a football. Perhaps they're throwing a frisbee. Perhaps they're just running around being kids.

Along comes a dog owner, opens the gate and lets the dog off its lead.

Let's call it a Doberman.

Although it could just as easily be a German Shepherd, a Labrador or a Shih Tzu wearing a pink bow. The breed is irrelevant.

"Don't worry, he's friendly!"

Wonderful.

Perhaps one child has previously been bitten by a dog.

Perhaps another is terrified.

Perhaps their football has been punctured by one before.

Or perhaps, and here's a radical thought, they simply want to play without somebody else's dog joining in.

But never mind.

It's a shared community space.

And if the children are frightened?

Well, presumably they can go somewhere else.

Perhaps they should lodge a submission.

Or request a community consultation.

Possibly a feasibility study into alternative frisbee locations.

Hobart City Council does enjoy a process.

Meanwhile, Back in the Chamber

A dog wanders around.

A councillor feels uncomfortable.

He raises his concern.

The Lord Mayor retrieves the dog and offers not to bring him again.

Problem identified. Problem addressed.

Remarkable.

Briefly.

First Dusty wasn't coming back.

Then he was, but on a leash.

Then the Lord Mayor needed to seek further information on council policy.

Ah.

There it is.

For one glorious moment, I thought Hobart City Council had discovered how to make a decision without further investigation.

Somewhere, a working group is putting the kettle on.

Protocol and Courtesy

Councillor Dutta told the Mercury that those working in the council chamber "ought to be asked beforehand if they feel comfortable. It's a matter of protocol and courtesy."

Well, Mike.

I couldn't have put it better myself.

In fact, I wish you'd said that during the D'Arcy Street debate. It might have saved us all a considerable amount of time, not to mention several forests' worth of correspondence.

Dutta was previously bitten by a dog that apparently looked very similar to Dusty.

So his discomfort is entirely understandable.

But imagine if one of our six children had said exactly the same thing.

Would their discomfort have been enough?

Or would they have been given a little lecture about sharing community spaces and learning to accommodate other users?

Perhaps they should have requested a formal meeting with the Lord Mayor.

Apparently, protocol and courtesy are relatively straightforward concepts when you're sitting around the council table.

A little more complicated when you're six years old and trying to kick a football.

Funny how the view changes depending on which side of the gate you're standing.

Thank You, Dusty

I have absolutely nothing against Dusty.

In fact, I think he's magnificent.

He's achieved more for the D'Arcy Street argument in one council meeting than years of correspondence.

Without making a speech.

Without lodging a motion.

Without commissioning a consultant.

Without even being a registered elector.

And he's already managed to generate three different positions on council dog policy in less than 24 hours.

That's an impressive political debut.

Frankly, he may be the most effective contributor to Hobart local government in quite some time.

Although perhaps somebody should explain the meaning of "come here".

But I do have one final suggestion.

Perhaps the next time Hobart City Council debates whether dogs should be allowed back onto South Hobart Oval, we could invite six children into the chamber.

Give them a football and a frisbee.

Let them run around the councillors' desks for a while.

And when somebody complains that they're disrupting proceedings, we can simply explain:

"Don't worry. They're friendly."

After all, it's a shared community space.

Isn't it?

Next
Next

The Australian Championship: Winning the League Is the Easy Part