Why on Earth Would You Want an A-League Team?

The $140 million question, disappearing crowds and the children's inheritance.

I've been wondering about Tasmania's A-League ambitions.

Most of you know I was on Tasmania's A-League bid team and was devastated when we were left out.

So you'd think I'd be first in the queue for the next one.

I'm not.

I'm sitting on the fence.

I'd love a Tasmanian team. I'd love our young players to turn professional without packing a bag for the mainland. I'd love to watch us take on the best in the country.

But there's an awkward question.

Who is going to pay for it?

Who is going to keep paying for it?

I've just read Samantha Lewis's investigation into the A-Leagues' finances.

I've come to a conclusion.

Owning a professional football club might be the quickest way to spend the children's inheritance.

The $140 million 101

Samantha Lewis does the hard yards.

While the rest of us argue about the referee, she's reading the fine print.

Her ESPN investigation, A-Leagues' financial woes: How solvent is Australia's top tier?, came out this week. It's well worth your time.

But dear modern reader, I know "private equity" isn't everyone's idea of a good night in.

So here's the 101.

In December 2021 American investment firm Silver Lake paid $140 million for a third of the Australian Professional Leagues.

That's the APL. They run our men's and women's A-Leagues.

By the end of 2023 almost all of it had been spent.

That's not me saying it. That's APL chairman Stephen Conroy.

Where did it go?

COVID took a big chunk. Teams had to be housed interstate when borders shut. Clubs needed propping up when the crowds disappeared.

Fair enough.

Then there was the rebrand.

About $5 million to bring the men's and women's competitions under one A-Leagues banner.

Including a reported $750,000 for a new song.

Seven hundred and fifty thousand dollars.

For a song.

Pick me!

I'd have written them one for half that. It would have rhymed too.

Then there was KeepUp.

Remember KeepUp?

I do. I used it.

It was clunky. It was hard to find anything. It told me what my other football apps already told me.

I never worked out what problem it was meant to solve.

I'm not sure the APL did either.

Around $20 million went into building it. Another $15 to $20 million went into a content team to fill it.

It was shut down in January 2024.

Thirty-five to forty million dollars to find out we liked the apps we already had.

According to Samantha, the APL recorded a $64 million loss in 2023. Then $44 million in 2024.

By the end of the 2024 financial year it had just over $5 million in cash left.

Since then it has cut hard. Club distributions dropped from about $2.3 million to just over $500,000. Almost half the staff went.

In 2025 it reported a preliminary operating profit.

$1.7 million.

After losing more than $100 million in two years.

I'll take good news where I can get it. But that's a long way back.

Getting in is one thing

Clubs don't just join the A-League.

Some of them fall out of it.

The New Zealand Knights lasted two seasons.

North Queensland Fury signed Robbie Fowler and still lasted only two. Their licence was revoked in 2011 when the money ran out.

Gold Coast United lasted three. Their licence was revoked in 2012 after a very public falling out with owner Clive Palmer.

Perth Glory went into receivership in 2023.

Newcastle Jets were kept afloat by other club owners until a buyer came along.

The Central Coast Mariners' owner handed the licence back in 2025.

Then Western United fell over.

That one was personal.

My son Max worked at Western for years. He had friends there, and still has, who were deeply hurt when it all came apart.

We lived and breathed it in our house.

People lost jobs. Players lost a club. Supporters lost their team.

The club went into hibernation in September 2025. In August this year the APL terminated its participation agreement.

Its owners say they want to come back.

I hope they do.

Western United was also the club that brought A-League games back to Tasmania in 2021.

Right now it isn't playing at all.

So when people talk about a Tasmanian licence, I don't just think about the launch.

I think about what happens if it goes wrong.

There's also the small matter of Silver Lake.

Their deal has never been made public. Samantha pieced it together from corporate documents and sources.

Here's what she found.

In June 2029 Silver Lake can make the APL buy back its stake at market value.

If the league is worth less than they paid, they can take a bigger share of the APL instead.

They're entitled to a 3% dividend every year. By 2029 that's more than $30 million.

If the APL were ever liquidated, Silver Lake would reportedly be paid before other shareholders.

Everyone else would get whatever was left.

If anything was left.

Samantha also reports the APL has negative net equity of about $170 million.

In plain English, on paper its liabilities outweigh its assets by that much. Almost all of it reflects Silver Lake's investment and the dividends piling up.

That's not a $170 million bill due tomorrow.

But it's not nothing either.

So if you're a Tasmanian investor thinking of buying in, you wouldn't just be joining a competition.

You'd be joining a queue.

With an American private equity firm standing at the front of it.

But where are all the supporters?

When the A-League started there was real excitement.

New clubs. New rivalries. Big crowds.

In 2007–08 the average men's crowd was approaching 15,000.

Last season it was about 8,880.

To be fair, it hasn't been a straight line down. The derbies still pull big numbers. Streaming audiences are growing.

The APL says this season has started with its best average crowds since 2019–20.

Good.

But it's still a long way from where it started.

Crowds matter.

A professional club needs people buying tickets. Memberships. A pie and a drink at half time. A scarf for the grandkids.

It needs sponsors who believe people are watching.

It needs broadcasters willing to pay to show the games.

In Australia football is fighting for every one of those dollars.

AFL. Rugby league. Rugby union. Cricket. Basketball.

They all want the same supporters, sponsors and airtime.

Football has huge numbers of children playing. Every Saturday morning our grounds are full.

But those families don't automatically become A-League members.

Loving football and loving the A-League are two different things.

If England can't make it pay

England is the home of football.

It's not one sport among many there. It's the sport.

Clubs passed down from grandparents. Wall-to-wall coverage and discussion. Television deals worth eye-watering sums.

If owning a football club was ever going to make money, surely it would be there.

Apparently not.

Last month England's Independent Football Regulator released its draft State of the Game report.

English football brought in about £9 billion last season.

And 94% of clubs in the top five divisions lost money.

Ninety-four per cent.

Nearly two-thirds of clubs in the EFL and National League are technically insolvent. That means they owe more than they own.

More than a quarter of clubs said they couldn't survive a month if their owners stopped putting money in.

Seventeen clubs would have lost money even if their players had played for free.

The regulator's chair, David Kogan, described English football as the richest in the world while also standing "on the edge of financial disaster".

Now try making that work in Australia.

A smaller market. Huge travel distances.

So why would anyone buy a football club?

Prestige. Passion. Pride in their city.

The thrill of owning the club they've loved all their life.

The belief that they'll be the clever one who finally gets it right.

Occasionally somebody does.

But I do hope the children aren't counting on that inheritance.

What about a derby?

One thing the A-League does well is rivalries.

Sydney FC v Western Sydney Wanderers.

Melbourne Victory v Melbourne City.

Last season's biggest crowd was a Sydney derby. More than 33,000 people.

There's the F3 Derby between Newcastle Jets and Central Coast Mariners, named after the old freeway that joins them.

My favourite is the Distance Derby between Perth Glory and Wellington Phoenix.

More than 5,000 kilometres apart.

So a derby doesn't need two teams sharing a postcode.

But a Tasmanian team wouldn't arrive with a ready-made rival. There'd be no thousands of opposition supporters just down the road.

Unless we did what Tasmania does best.

One team in Hobart. One in Launceston.

The Midlands Derby!

North v south. Old grudges dusted off. Supporters arguing over which end of the highway is the true centre of Tasmanian civilisation.

The trophy could be a Midlands Highway roadworks sign.

There's just one small problem.

We're still working out how to pay for one team.

Two would need somebody to win Powerball.

More than once.

So the Midlands Derby might have to stay a lovely idea.

And where would we play?

The stadium matters too.

And no, I don't mean another Mac Point.

If Tasmania ever gets an A-League team, I want it in a small stadium where you can hear, see and feel the football.

I spend a lot of time on the sideline. I know what football sounds like up close.

Players calling to each other.

The thud of the ball being struck.

Coaches yelling from the technical area.

You see the tackles. The skill. The frustration. The celebrations.

A few thousand people in the right-sized ground can make a terrific noise.

The same crowd in a big stadium disappears into a sea of empty seats.

Football deserves to be watched close up.

A small stadium that's regularly full beats a big one that's mostly empty.

It would still need to meet A-League standards for players, officials, broadcasters and spectators.

But bigger isn't always better.

Especially when you're building something from scratch.

Would the government come to the party?

Football Tasmania's 2024–2028 Strategic Plan includes an ambition to deliver a Tasmanian A-League club.

That's quite a vision.

But I can't picture the Tasmanian Government looking at the A-League's books and saying, "Now there's a smart investment."

It already has plenty on its plate.

The AFL team. Macquarie Point. The AFL high-performance centre. The JackJumpers.

Meanwhile football clubs around the state are still asking for decent grounds. Lights. Drainage. Changerooms.

Our clubs need backing first.

So if we're struggling to pay for the football facilities we need now, where would the millions for an A-League team come from?

Would taxpayers be expected to chip in?

And how does government decide what's good value anyway?

Take Scott Roth.

In May the JackJumpers coach was signed as a Tasmanian ambassador on a $95,000 contract.

Last week he was also named our first Biosecurity Ambassador. That's covered by the same contract.

Ninety-five thousand dollars.

Where do I apply?

I'd happily stand at Hobart Airport welcoming visitors to our beautiful island.

I'd point them to the baggage carousel. Tell them where to get a decent coffee. Give the detector dog a pat.

I might check with biosecurity before offering it a biscuit.

I don't begrudge Scott his popularity. He's done a lot for Tasmanian basketball. Biosecurity matters on an island.

But it does make you wonder how these decisions get made.

If a basketball coach is worth $95,000 as an ambassador, what would a government expect to spend on an A-League club?

And would it be the best use of our money?

Before anyone signs anything

If a private investor wants to put their own money into a Tasmanian A-League team, knowing the risks, good luck to them.

That's their call.

But if public money is involved, we're entitled to ask what we're actually trying to achieve.

If it's professional opportunities for our best young players, is an A-League club the only way?

If it's growing football across Tasmania, the same money could buy a lot of synthetic pitches.

A successful professional club could lift the whole game.

But money spent at the top doesn't automatically trickle down to the bottom.

So I'd want some answers.

  • How many members could we realistically sign up?

  • How much sponsorship is out there when the Devils, the JackJumpers and every local club are already knocking on the same doors?

  • What does it cost to fly a squad around Australia and New Zealand every second week?

  • Would there be a women's team from day one?

  • How would it connect with our clubs, the NPL and our pathways?

  • How many Tasmanian players would actually make the squad?

  • Who covers the losses if it doesn't work?

  • What happens to the players, staff and supporters if it folds?

That last one isn't hypothetical.

Ask anyone who was at Western United.

So, would I like a Tasmanian A-League team?

I'm still on the fence.

Of course I can see the appeal. I've been there. I've wanted it badly.

But wanting something and being able to afford it are two different things.

Right now the numbers don't make it easy.

Perhaps somebody will come along with a brilliant plan, deep pockets and a real love of Tasmanian football.

I hope they do.

But before they sign anything, I'd suggest they read Samantha Lewis's investigation.

Then England's State of the Game report.

Then have a very long conversation with their accountant.

Then a quiet word with the children about their inheritance.

Further reading

Previous
Previous

Surprise, Surprise. Or Perhaps Not.

Next
Next

The American Edition: Soccer, Politics and Shithouses