Yes, AI made it.
It's recruitment season in Tasmanian football. Everyone is wanted, everyone has a future and apparently there's a starting position for everybody.
It's that time of year again.
The football season is over, the presentations are finished and the recruiting has begun.
And suddenly everybody is wanted.
"Come and play for us. You'll be in my starting eleven."
"We're building something special."
"You'll get plenty of game time."
"We can pay you."
"Come and play NPL."
"Come and play WSL."
Promises, promises, promises.
I sometimes wonder how many starting eleven positions are promised around Tasmania between October and February. There must be enough to field another twenty teams.
All before anybody has kicked a ball.
Recruiting is part of football. Clubs want to improve. Coaches want stronger squads. Players are entitled to explore their options.
But there's a difference between offering somebody an opportunity and making a promise you cannot possibly keep.
The Starting Eleven
This is the one that really gets me.
How can any coach promise a player a starting position before a ball has been kicked?
Do they know who they'll face next season?
Do they know what formation they'll need?
Do they know whether that wonderful new signing will be the best player for a particular match?
The opposition might require a different shape. The experienced player who was supposedly being replaced might be the better option.
A young player who wasn't even in the coach's plans in October might have a brilliant preseason and deserve to start.
Isn't that what coaches are employed to do? Make those decisions and win football matches.
At NPL and WSL level, results matter. Coaches are under pressure and their jobs can depend on it.
So when Saturday arrives, what happens to that promise made over a cup of coffee in November?
The coach picks the team they believe will win.
As they should.
And the disappointed recruit finds themselves on the bench.
"Don't worry, son. You'll get your chance next week."
Next week arrives. Different opposition. Different circumstances.
Same bench.
Eventually that player starts wondering whether leaving their old club was such a good idea after all.
Even the Professionals Know Better
I was listening recently to former Melbourne Victory player and now football agent Fahid Ben Khalfallah on the Suited & Booted podcast.
He was talking about player recruitment and the promises clubs make.
His response to the idea that a club could guarantee a player a starting position was pretty straightforward.
"That's a lie."
He explained that coaches want to succeed and will select the players they believe give them the best chance of doing so.
He made another point every player should remember.
"The coach can be gone in three weeks."
Exactly.
You might change clubs because a coach has promised you the world, only to find the person who made those promises has moved on.
When negotiating transfers, Ben Khalfallah tries to involve not just the coach but the sporting director and head of recruitment.
He wants to understand the club's philosophy and what the player is actually signing up for.
Because a club should be more than the promises of one person.
He also believes players have to take some responsibility for their decisions.
I agree.
If you're prepared to leave a club where you're happy because somebody has promised you the world over a coffee, you need to ask a few more questions.
If a professional agent calls a guaranteed starting spot a lie, how can a coach recruiting for next season's Tasmanian NPL or WSL promise one?
Yet apparently, over a cup of coffee, some coaches can guarantee a starting position, a premiership and a pathway to greatness.
All before the Christmas decorations have come down.
Come With Me. I'll Make It Happen.
Then there's the bigger sales pitch.
"Come with me to Club A."
"We're going to win the league."
"You'll get to play on the big stage."
"You need to put yourself in the window."
"People will see what a great player you are."
"I can get you noticed."
"I can do this for you."
I, I, I.
Quite a sales pitch, isn't it?
The player isn't just being offered a new club. They're being offered a future.
A chance to win something. To be noticed. To go further in the game.
And apparently the person making the offer has the power to make it all happen.
This goes on everywhere in football, not just Tasmania.
Coaches recruit. They sell their vision. They want players to believe in what they're building.
I understand that.
But nobody can promise a premiership.
Nobody can promise that scouts or selectors will notice a particular player.
Nobody can guarantee that changing clubs will open doors that would otherwise stay shut.
A good coach can provide opportunities. They can help a player improve and perhaps move to a higher level.
What they cannot do is guarantee the result.
Hands Up. I'm Part of This Too.
Before somebody rushes to remind me that I spent sixteen seasons as President of South Hobart, married to the coach, let me save you the trouble.
I know.
I'm sure there are people reading this with their own stories about recruitment at South Hobart. Some might even involve Ken.
I'm not going to pretend otherwise.
I wasn't involved in recruiting or signing players. I always believed there should be a separation between club administration and football decisions. A bit like church and state.
Admittedly, that's easier said than done when you live with the coach!
But I tried.
That doesn't mean I knew about every conversation or every promise that might have been made.
Nor does it mean South Hobart, Ken or I should be immune from criticism.
I've been in Tasmanian football long enough to know how competitive clubs become when they're chasing players and premierships.
That's why I think it's worth talking about.
This isn't about one coach or one club. It's about a culture we've all been part of, to varying degrees.
If we're going to question that culture, we should be prepared to look at ourselves as well.
The Football Tasmania Tracksuit
Then there's Football Tasmania.
What happens when a coach appointed to Football Tasmania's Talent Support Program or Academy is also coaching or recruiting at a club?
I've seen young players change clubs and end up with their Football Tasmania development coach as their new club coach.
I'm not saying anybody did anything wrong.
But it raises a question.
Does a Football Tasmania appointment give a coach an advantage when it comes to attracting young players?
I suspect it does.
I can already hear the response.
"Tasmania is a small place. We don't have enough coaches to keep those roles separate."
I agree.
We don't have an endless supply of qualified, experienced coaches waiting for an appointment.
Many of our best coaches already work in clubs. Some are volunteers, some are paid and many contribute in several ways.
It would be ridiculous to say everybody who works with Football Tasmania should be stopped from coaching at club level.
But that doesn't make the potential conflict of interest disappear.
It makes managing it more important.
When I considered nominating for the Football Tasmania board, the conflict of interest rules ruled out almost everybody with a club connection.
Yet a coach can run a Football Tasmania development program on Tuesday and recruit for their own club on Saturday.
If conflicts matter in the boardroom, surely they matter on the training pitch.
Imagine you're a parent.
Your daughter or son has been selected for a Football Tasmania development program.
You're thrilled. You want to give them every chance to succeed.
And there, running the sessions, is a coach in a Football Tasmania tracksuit.
Surely that person knows what they're talking about?
Surely Football Tasmania wouldn't have appointed them otherwise?
In your mind, that might make them a better coach than the one working with your child at their club.
But does it?
Of course not.
There are outstanding club coaches across Tasmania who have spent years developing players, building their confidence and understanding what makes them tick.
Some have qualifications and experience equal to or greater than those in representative programs.
They just don't have the Football Tasmania title.
That's the problem.
A Football Tasmania appointment carries authority. Intended or not, it can give that person's advice extra weight with players and parents.
So what happens when the conversation turns to club football?
"Have you thought about coming to our club?"
"I think you'd develop better playing with us."
"We can offer you more opportunities."
"We know what you need to get to the next level."
Now, whose advice is that?
The Football Tasmania development coach?
Or the club coach who would quite like another talented player in the squad?
The advice might be entirely genuine.
Changing clubs might really benefit the player.
But how is a parent supposed to know whether they're getting independent development advice or a recruitment pitch?
Here's another question.
Would a thirteen-year-old feel comfortable saying no to somebody they believe could influence their future selection?
Would their parents?
I'm not suggesting every coach with two roles behaves improperly. That would be unfair.
But the possibility of influence is there. That's enough to warrant some clear boundaries.
Football Tasmania's development programs are meant to complement club football. They are not meant to be recruiting grounds for individual clubs.
So Football Tasmania should be clear about what is acceptable.
Can a development coach approach players in their program about joining their own club?
Should that coach have to declare their club affiliation to players and parents?
What happens if a parent feels pressured?
How does Football Tasmania make sure a player's willingness to change clubs has no bearing on their development opportunities?
We don't need to ban coaches from holding more than one role.
We need transparency, clear expectations and a real separation between the responsibilities of each.
A Football Tasmania appointment comes with more than a tracksuit.
Parents trust it.
And that trust shouldn't be used to fill a club's squad on a Saturday.
The Girls Super League?
There's talk of the Women's Super League being rebranded.
Well, I've got a suggestion.
Why not call it the Girls Super League?
The players seem to be getting younger and younger.
Before anybody gets upset, I'm not criticising the girls. Far from it. We have some wonderfully talented young female footballers in Tasmania.
But we should be asking why our premier women's competition is becoming so dependent on teenagers.
Where are the experienced women? Why aren't we keeping more of them?
With a relatively small pool of aspiring female players, imagine the recruiting pressure on those talented young girls and their families.
The promises. The pathways. The opportunities.
"Come and play WSL."
"You'll get plenty of minutes."
"You'll develop much faster."
"We can help you get noticed."
"We've got a pathway for you."
And sometimes the person making those promises might also be involved in her Football Tasmania development program.
Clubs need players. Coaches need results. A talented teenager suddenly becomes a very attractive target.
Is she being recruited because the move is in her best interests?
Or because a WSL coach needs another player in the squad?
Sometimes it's both.
Parents deserve to know which.
Playing senior football young can be a wonderful experience. But being picked in a WSL squad isn't the same as being ready for senior football.
Sitting on a WSL bench isn't necessarily better development than playing every week in the right competition.
We talk endlessly about pathways.
But a pathway should be about the player, not about getting her into somebody's first-team squad.
Rather than worrying about what we call the competition, we should be asking why we aren't keeping more adult women in it.
And Then There's the Money
Let's talk about money.
There's nothing wrong with players being paid.
If a club wants to pay somebody to play and can honour that commitment, good luck to both of them.
Players give up a great deal of time. Training, travel, matches and the physical toll of playing at a competitive level.
Some know they don't have many seasons left.
If another club offers them more money, I understand why they'd take it.
Fair enough.
But why do we feel the need to dress it up as something else?
"I'm looking for a new challenge."
"I really believe in what they're building."
"It's a great opportunity for my football."
Maybe it is.
But if the main reason you're moving is that somebody is paying you more, just say so.
There's no shame in it.
Not every player who changes clubs has suddenly discovered a better football philosophy.
Sometimes the football philosophy comes with a weekly payment.
And players should know exactly what they're being offered.
If somebody promises you $200 a week, is that guaranteed?
Or do you have to start?
Do you have to play 60 minutes?
What happens if you're injured?
The coach who promises you game time may be the same person deciding whether you've earned your payment.
Worth thinking about before you agree to anything.
What About Loyalty?
Loyalty is an interesting word in football.
We expect it from players, yet spend months encouraging players from other clubs to leave.
We celebrate somebody who stays with us for years, then get excited when we persuade a long-serving player from somewhere else to switch.
We criticise players who leave for money but happily offer money to attract somebody else's best player.
We could be a little more consistent.
And spare a thought for the player who has been at a club for years, trained hard, done everything asked of them, then discovers somebody recruited over summer has been promised their position.
What does that do to trust within a squad?
Players are entitled to make their own decisions.
Clubs are entitled to recruit.
Coaches are entitled to build competitive squads.
But honesty should be part of the process.
Promises Are Easy
I love the optimism of a new football season.
New players, new coaches, new ambitions. Everybody believes this could be their year.
But being wanted in October doesn't mean being selected in March.
Parents and players should ask questions.
What exactly is being offered?
What happens if the coach leaves?
Is this advice from somebody whose job is to develop the player, or somebody who needs to strengthen their club?
Come the first game of the season, there will still only be eleven players in the starting side.
And I suspect rather more than eleven were promised a place.
So if somebody can promise you a starting position, a premiership and a wonderful football future over a cup of coffee, just enjoy the coffee.
Had promises made to you or your child? Have your say in my independent State of Tasmanian Football survey, open until Sunday 15 November. [Take the survey here]