The State of Tasmanian Football 2026. An independent survey inviting the football community to have its say.
When people stop speaking up because they believe nothing will change, what does that say about the state of our game?
I've been thinking a lot lately about having a voice in Tasmanian football.
Not just my voice. Everyone's.
We all have opinions about the game. How it's run, the competitions we play in, the pathways for young players, what it costs to participate and where football is heading.
Some people are happy with the way things are going. Others are deeply frustrated. Most, I suspect, sit somewhere in between.
But where do we go to have those conversations?
I hear people question decisions or vent about something happening at their club. Quite often the conversation ends with a shrug.
"What's the point? Nothing will change."
That bothers me.
Not because I expect everyone to agree with me. Not because every complaint should lead to a change.
It bothers me because nobody should feel that speaking up is a waste of time.
I wonder how many people have simply stopped trying.
If people have stopped expecting anyone to listen, how would we even know what they wanted to tell us?
Where do we have these conversations?
At the moment there aren't many public places to talk about football in Tasmania.
There's Tassie Football Central, where people comment on Facebook. Sometimes anonymously.
There's my blog, where I write about the things that interest or concern me.
And there's Walter Pless, who has contributed so much to football discussion in Tasmania over the years.
But none of these is a formal consultation process.
They're places to share opinions, debate decisions and sometimes let off steam. They have their place. They're not the same as being consulted.
Facebook can also turn nasty very quickly. A reasonable concern gets buried under personal attacks and the inevitable arguments.
Recently someone questioned how I could write about kindness towards an individual while criticising an organisation.
I don't see a contradiction.
We can question decisions, challenge the people responsible for them and still treat one another with decency.
Being kind doesn't mean keeping quiet.
And having strong opinions doesn't mean we abandon decency.
Because when discussions turn personal, plenty of people decide it's easier to say nothing.
Being heard doesn't mean getting your own way
Consultation doesn't mean everyone gets what they want.
Football is full of competing interests. No governing body can keep everybody happy.
But there's a difference between making an unpopular decision after genuinely listening and simply announcing it.
People may be more willing to accept an outcome they don't like if they understand why it was made. They need to believe their views were considered.
I should say that Tony Pignata has picked up the phone to talk about issues I've raised in my writing. I commend him for that. I can contact him directly and he has been willing to engage.
Not everyone has a blog.
Not everyone is comfortable speaking publicly.
Not everyone wants to challenge a decision under their own name on Facebook.
Those people deserve a voice too.
A conversation with the CEO, however welcome, can't replace a process that lets the wider football community take part.
What about the people we never hear from?
There's something else that has been on my mind.
When I write, I tend to concentrate on the things that concern me.
But what about the things I don't see?
What about the parent whose child has stopped playing?
What about the volunteer who is exhausted?
What about the referee who has had enough?
What about the club struggling to keep its doors open?
What about the person who thinks football in Tasmania is going rather well and wonders why the rest of us are always complaining?
Their experiences matter just as much as mine.
Maybe that's one of the problems with the way we discuss football. We hear from the people prepared to speak publicly. Others quietly get on with things or simply walk away.
And we don't always know why.
That's why I don't want to ask people whether they agree with me. I want to know what matters to them.
I suspect there's quite a lot happening in Tasmanian football that those of us who spend our time talking about the game know very little about.
What would genuine consultation look like?
Why couldn't Football Tasmania hold regular forums across the South, North and North West?
Not presentations where decisions are explained after they've been made. Real discussions where people can ask questions, raise concerns and suggest improvements.
What about an independent facilitator, so people feel comfortable speaking openly and the discussion doesn't become a confrontation?
What about regular surveys, with the results shared and responses given to the issues raised?
And I don't just mean asking clubs to send a representative to a meeting.
Players, parents, coaches, referees, volunteers and supporters are all part of the game. They experience it differently. They all have something worth contributing.
There would be disagreement. Probably plenty of it.
But isn't that the point of consultation?
You listen. You consider different views. You explain your decisions.
And sometimes, hopefully, you change your mind.
So why not start with a very simple question?
Do you feel heard?
If the answer is no, surely that's worth understanding.
So I've decided to ask
I've put together an independent survey called The State of Tasmanian Football 2026.
It isn't commissioned or endorsed by Football Tasmania. It's mine.
I'd particularly welcome responses from people who disagree with me.
I want to know what you think is working well. What concerns you. Whether you feel heard. What you'd most like to see happen over the next three years.
It's open to players, parents, coaches, referees, volunteers, administrators and supporters from right across the state.
Responses have already started coming in. I won't discuss them until the survey closes.
Will it make a difference?
I don't know.
Maybe it won't.
Maybe people will fill it in, I'll publish the results and nothing will happen.
But perhaps some clear themes will emerge.
Perhaps people in different regions, clubs and levels of the game share concerns that haven't been recognised.
Perhaps we'll find things football is doing well and should build on.
Or perhaps we'll discover that the things I worry about aren't particularly important to other people at all.
That would be worth knowing too.
And perhaps, if enough people say similar things, someone in a position to make decisions will listen.
I can't promise anyone will act on the findings.
I can promise I'll report them fairly. That includes the responses that challenge my own views.
It isn't a scientific poll. The results won't speak for everyone in Tasmanian football. But it could be a starting point for a bigger conversation.
I think that's worth a go.
The alternative is that we keep having the same conversations. We keep shrugging. Nothing changes.
I'd rather ask the question.
The State of Tasmanian Football 2026: Have Your Say
The survey takes about five minutes. No name or email address is required. I'll publish only summarised findings and won't identify individual respondents.
It closes on Sunday 15 November 2026 at 11:45 pm, Tasmanian time. I'll publish a summary of the findings afterwards.
Complete the survey here: