140 clubs in revolt. A President's heartfelt appeal. And the rather awkward question of whether football clubs are allowed to complain.
More than 140 football clubs are in revolt against Football Queensland (FQ).
A proposed fee model has been dumped. Lawyers are involved. Clubs are pushing for an Extraordinary General Meeting.
And the President has published an extraordinary statement about bullying, harassment and intimidation.
Sitting in the middle of all this is a fascinating question. Are clubs actually allowed to criticise the organisation that governs them?
From down here in Tasmania it's quite the show.
So grab a cuppa. Here's how we got here.
Football Queensland 101: What's Everyone Fighting About?
It started with money.
Doesn't it always?
In early October Football Queensland announced a new Competition Access Fee (CAF) model for 2027.
FQ said it would simplify fees and administration. The overall cost to participants would stay broadly the same as 2026.
The clubs weren't buying it.
Rabieh Krayem, President of Wynnum Wolves, wrote to FQ on behalf of 71 clubs. He ran the new model over his own club and calculated its charges payable to FQ would jump by 64.6 per cent.
That's not a 64.6 per cent increase in every player's registration fee. An important distinction.
But it was enough to set alarm bells ringing.
FQ pushed back hard. It said Queensland's fees were the lowest in the country. It also pointed out that 90 to 97 per cent of the fees participants pay go to clubs, not to FQ.
The clubs had questions of their own.
Where was the money going? Why hadn't they been properly consulted? And how exactly were they meant to explain this to families already stretched by the cost of junior sport?
More than 100 clubs joined forces.
Within weeks the campaign, calling itself Football Clubs United, had more than 140 clubs behind it. They have a Facebook page called exactly this. Grab the popcorn.
On 16 October FQ blinked.
It dropped the proposed Competition Access Fee model and kept its existing fee structure for 2027. FQ says individual fees will still be adjusted for inflation and transaction and technology costs.
Game over?
Not even close.
From Fees to Fine Print
The clubs turned their attention to the 2027 affiliation agreement.
For the uninitiated, this is an agreement Queensland clubs must enter into with Football Queensland to participate in the affiliated football system.
Here in Tasmania we're familiar with participation agreements and licensing requirements for the NPL and Women's Premier League (formerly Women's Super League).
But Queensland has an overarching annual affiliation agreement for its clubs, separate from any additional licensing requirements for its higher-level competitions.
And this is where things started getting interesting.
The clubs raised concerns about consultation, financial transparency, restrictions on what clubs can say and the powers FQ holds over its member clubs.
There was also a row over a $35 per-player fee for off-season competitions run by the clubs themselves. Why, the clubs asked, should they pay the federation for competitions they largely organise and fund?
Football Clubs United later reported the fee had come down to $10.
The clubs still want to know why there's a fee at all.
They also wanted more time to consider the agreement.
FQ initially set a 31 October deadline, which it later extended to 13 November.
Then on 6 November Football Clubs United announced that lawyers acting for the clubs had written to Zone Committee members. They were asking for support for an Extraordinary General Meeting.
This was no longer an argument about registration fees.
It was now about how football is governed. Who makes the decisions. And how much say the clubs really have.
Sanctioning. Now There's Another Story.
Just when I thought I'd got my head around the fees and affiliation agreements, along came FQ's sanctioning policy.
Holiday clinics. Development programs. Summer competitions. Friendly matches. Club functions. End-of-season presentations.
Quite a list.
Before anyone in Tasmania gets too smug, we have sanctioning here too.
And for good reason.
I arrange sanctioning for the Hobart Cup every year. We also have requirements for touring teams and tournaments.
Insurance matters. So does risk management.
And when I pay Football Tasmania for referees at the Hobart Cup, there's an administration fee for organising them.
Fair enough. That's a service and someone has to do the work.
But we don't have to ask Football Tasmania for permission to hold our ordinary end-of-season presentations.
Imagine emailing FT.
Dear Football Tasmania,
We're holding our junior presentation on 10 September.
We'd like to give our five-year-olds a sausage and a medal.
Is that alright with you?
And imagine the reply.
Dear Club,
Yes, that's fine.
That'll be twenty bucks, thanks.
I mean, seriously.
Queensland was once famous for Joh Bjelke-Petersen's "Don't you worry about that."
Now it seems clubs might have to worry about just about everything.
Joh would be turning in his grave.
White shoes and all.
To be fair, FQ doesn't charge a sanctioning application fee for ordinary end-of-season presentations.
But clubs still have to lodge them for approval.
A sausage and a medal. Permission required.
That raises questions about how far the governing body's reach extends.
And then there's the money.
Under FQ's 2027 sanctioning policy, a three-hour holiday clinic charging $50 per child can attract a $3.30 fee per participant.
Fifty children. That's $165 to FQ.
For a clinic the club organises, staffs and runs.
FQ runs its own Academy holiday clinics too.
Here in Tasmania, Football Tasmania runs its own holiday clinics. So do its affiliated clubs.
Imagine if FT decided to charge clubs a fee for every child attending their clinics while running competing programs of its own.
I'd have a few questions.
Starting with who gets to make the rules when the rule-maker is also competing for the same children.
I'm not against sanctioning.
I'm against unnecessary bureaucracy and fees that aren't clearly justified.
At what point do clubs get to run their own clubs?
And Then the President Spoke
Last night, 7 November, I was multitasking on the couch when up popped a statement from Football Queensland President Paula Robinson.
Yes, scrolling the feed again.
It was titled A Call for Respect and Leadership in Queensland Football.
And it was quite something.
Read Paula Robinson's full statement
Robinson spoke about bullying, intimidation and harassment directed at people involved in football administration.
She said some volunteer Zone Committee members had resigned and that she'd considered resigning herself.
She also pointed to concessions FQ had made, including withdrawing the proposed fee model and amending parts of the affiliation agreement.
She said the Board had resisted calls to pursue legal or disciplinary action.
I've spent enough years in football administration to know how unpleasant things can get.
Volunteers don't deserve personal abuse. Neither do paid administrators.
And if people have been bullied or threatened, that's unacceptable.
But there's another side to this.
Clubs organising themselves, asking questions about fees, challenging governance arrangements and seeking an Extraordinary General Meeting aren't necessarily bullying anyone.
They're exercising their rights as members of a sporting organisation.
You can condemn personal abuse without dismissing legitimate criticism.
You Can Complain. But Who Decides Whether You're Allowed To?
Now here's something that really caught my attention.
Back in 2022, Football Queensland's affiliation policy included restrictions on clubs making adverse, critical or disparaging statements about FQ, Football Australia, competitions or even football in general.
Football in general.
So no grumbling about VAR then?
Fast forward to the 2027 affiliation agreement.
Clubs questioned a clause restricting public criticism and asked who would decide whether they'd breached it.
FQ's response, published in its affiliation FAQs, was rather revealing.
"Criticism is highly subjective, and FQ considers it reasonable that FQ be the arbiter of what constitutes a breach."
Yes, really.
The organisation being criticised considers it reasonable that it should decide whether the criticism breaches its own affiliation agreement.
To be fair, this doesn't mean FQ gets to decide every complaint against itself. There are other processes and legal avenues.
FQ also says its provisions are there to protect people from unacceptable conduct and reflect national football standards.
But it does mean clubs face the prospect of their governing body judging whether their public criticism has crossed a line.
Here in Tasmania, clubs and officials are bound by Football Australia's codes of conduct too.
Fair enough. Nobody should have a licence to abuse people.
But I haven't found an equivalent Football Tasmania provision that expressly makes FT the judge of whether its member clubs have been too critical of FT itself.
There's a difference between regulating misconduct and regulating criticism.
It's an important one.
Which raises a rather obvious question.
Who holds the governing body accountable when the governing body also makes the rules about what its members can say?
A Cautionary Tale: My Friend Bonita Mersiades
So, as a relatively new blogger, am I cautious about what I write for fear of litigation?
Damn right I am.
Super cautious.
And there's a Queensland football story that explains why.
In 2020, then Football Queensland President Ben Richardson and CEO Robert Cavallucci brought defamation proceedings against football writer Bonita Mersiades.
They sought a combined $800,000 in damages.
The matter was settled in February 2021. Bonita issued a retraction and apology. A payment was made under terms that were not publicly disclosed. FQ said the payment would be directed to football charities.
Read FQ's statement on the 2021 settlement and apology
I'm not going to revisit the allegations that were the subject of those proceedings.
But there's another part of this story.
In November 2020, the ABC reported that FQ CEO Robert Cavallucci had threatened to deregister Wynnum Wolves after its President, Rabieh Krayem, publicly supported Bonita and helped raise funds for her legal defence.
That's an ABC report, not a finding by a court.
And who wrote to FQ on behalf of 71 clubs this October?
Rabieh Krayem.
Now here's where it gets personal.
I know Bonita. And I know Rabieh from our time together on the Association of Australian Football Clubs board.
Small world.
None of that proves FQ is acting improperly now.
But it does explain why clubs are twitchy about criticism clauses.
And why this particular blogger checks her facts very carefully.
What About Tasmania?
We have our disagreements with Football Tasmania too.
Of course we do.
And I've certainly had a few over the years.
During COVID, all eight NPL club presidents agreed we'd had enough of the licence fees.
So we organised ourselves.
Eight presidents. Eight emails withdrawing our clubs from the NPL.
All sent at exactly the same time.
In the immortal words of Sally Field in Norma Rae.
UNION.
At least I didn't have to stand on a table with a placard.
To his credit, then Football Tasmania President Bob Gordon sat down with us, negotiated and we reached agreement on a reduced licence fee.
We didn't always agree with Football Tasmania. We certainly weren't afraid to tell them.
But we found a way forward.
And isn't that how it should work?
Clubs should be able to question decisions, organise themselves and challenge their governing body without fearing for their place in the game.
That doesn't mean clubs are always right.
It means they deserve to be heard.
So Where Does This Leave Queensland?
Football Queensland has backed down on its proposed fee model.
The clubs have demonstrated what can happen when they organise themselves.
But the bigger questions haven't gone away.
Who makes the decisions? Who gets consulted?
And what happens when clubs disagree?
Paula Robinson has called for respect and leadership.
She's right to expect both.
But respect works both ways.
Clubs are not simply customers of a football federation. They're the people who deliver the game, week after week, supported by thousands of volunteers.
Without them, there isn't much football to govern.
I don't pretend to know everything that's happened behind the scenes in Queensland.
And I'm certainly not suggesting every complaint made by the clubs is justified.
But asking questions about fees, demanding transparency and seeking a say in how your sport is governed should never be treated as disloyalty.
That's part of being a member of a sporting organisation.
As for me, I'll keep asking questions.
Carefully, of course.
Very carefully.