A conversation with Ned, a spreadsheet and the cost of trying to compete with the big boys.
One of my sons, Ned, is a student of philosophy.
While I'm listening to podcasts about history and politics he's listening to Edward de Bono and Jean-Paul Sartre.
For anyone unfamiliar with them, de Bono was the man who popularised lateral thinking. Looking at a problem from a different angle.
Sartre was a French philosopher concerned with freedom, choice and responsibility.
I suspect Ned would have a rather more sophisticated explanation of both.
Anyway, we talk football a lot.
One conversation crops up again and again. Can a Tasmanian team ever really beat interstate opposition, whether in the Australia Cup or the Australian Championship?
Ned reckons a spreadsheet explains much of it.
Put the number of registered footballers in every state into a spreadsheet, he says. Look at the size of each talent pool and work out the odds.
Tasmania, with its tiny playing population, will always have the odds stacked against it.
I've been mulling over his argument since yesterday. South Hobart 2, Lions FC 4 at D'Arcy Street.
It sent me back to a book that has sat on my bookshelf for years.
Soccernomics.
Soccernomics. A quick refresher.
Soccernomics, by Simon Kuper and Stefan Szymanski, was first published in 2009.
It uses economics and statistics to look at football. It's an entertaining read and it challenges a lot of what we assume about why teams win and lose.
One of its findings is that international football success comes down largely to three things. Population, wealth and football experience.
Simple enough ideas, but they're easier to see with a few football examples.
Population.
The bigger the pool of footballers, the better your chance of finding exceptional ones.
Brazil has more than 200 million people. Uruguay has around 3.4 million.
Yet Uruguay has won two World Cups and keeps producing outstanding players.
Population gives you an advantage. It doesn't decide the result.
Wealth.
Money pays for coaching, facilities and development programs. All the things that help good players become better ones.
A wealthy European football nation can invest far more in its players than a poorer country of similar size.
But spending a lot of money isn't the same as spending it wisely.
Football experience.
This was the part that interested me most.
Countries with long football histories have built up generations of coaching knowledge, strong competitions and experience against the best.
Take the Netherlands, with around 18 million people.
Japan has about 124 million, plenty of money and a real love of the game. But its professional league only started in 1993.
The Dutch have a century of football behind them and have reached three World Cup finals.
Japan has been catching up fast, as its own football experience builds.
The authors found that accumulated football experience mattered more than population.
That's important for Tasmania.
We can't do much about our population.
We can do something about the football we produce.
Soccernomics is mostly about international football and big professional clubs, not the Tasmanian NPL. But the ideas travel.
Ned's spreadsheet
Football Australia's 2025 National Participation Report gives these numbers for registered outdoor footballers.
State Players
Tasmania 15,193
Victoria 96,095
Queensland 104,690
NSW including Northern NSW 321,777
NSW has more than 21 times as many registered outdoor footballers as Tasmania.
Queensland has nearly seven times as many.
Victoria has more than six times as many.
The senior men's numbers are even more lopsided.
State Senior males
Tasmania 1,713
Victoria 14,651
Queensland 16,869
NSW including Northern NSW 66,574
Nearly 39 senior male footballers in NSW for every one in Tasmania.
One qualification. Tasmania runs separate social leagues and other states may count some community football differently. So these aren't perfectly comparable measures of NPL-quality talent.
But however you slice it, Tasmania is heavily outnumbered.
Put simply, this is Ned's point.
Imagine one per cent of senior men in each state could play at a really high standard.
Tasmania would have about 17.
NSW would have about 666.
That's an illustration, not an estimate.
But you can see the problem.
Tasmania is trying to find a squad from a very small pool. The bigger states have hundreds of extra candidates.
And that's before coaching, facilities, professional pathways and money come into it.
Probability isn't certainty
If a team has a 20 per cent chance of winning, that doesn't mean it loses.
It means that if the same game could be played a hundred times, you'd expect that team to win about one in five.
It could win the first one. It could lose the next ten.
A 20 per cent chance is still a chance. And football is very good at producing unexpected results.
In October, South Hobart went to Brisbane. Lions FC 1, South Hobart 2.
Yesterday at D'Arcy Street. South Hobart 2, Lions FC 4.
Queensland's playing population didn't change between those two games. Neither did Tasmania's.
The result did.
So Ned's spreadsheet can help estimate the odds. It can't tell us who wins a particular game.
Population alone isn't enough to set the odds anyway. You'd also need the strength of each team, their experience, home ground and a few other things.
Otherwise the spreadsheet might as well pick the premiers before the season starts.
Think of the money we'd save.
Ned's spreadsheet looks at the odds.
My question is a different one.
Is changing those odds worth what it costs?
Can you buy your way out of a statistical disadvantage?
When South Hobart qualified for the inaugural Australian Championship in 2025, I argued against bringing in extra players just for the national competition.
My reasoning was simple.
We didn't have the money of the clubs we were about to face. We couldn't match their playing budgets.
So why try to buy our way to success?
We had a squad that had won the Tasmanian NPL and earned its place.
Why not back those players?
Why spend extra money trying to close a gap that a handful of recruits probably couldn't close?
There was another consideration.
What happens to the players who worked all season, won the premiership and qualified, only to be replaced by someone brought in for the national games?
How do they feel?
And do they come back next season?
For a Tasmanian club with such a small talent pool, those aren't small questions.
What does the money actually buy?
I'm doing what Ned does. Turning a question over to see what's underneath it.
One question runs right through Soccernomics.
What does the money actually buy?
So I've been asking that question about South Hobart.
In 2025, South Hobart went into the Australian Championship with the squad that won the Tasmanian NPL.
It finished fourth in its group.
Six games. No wins. One draw. Five losses.
This year the club strengthened the squad, including players recruited specifically for the Australian Championship.
And there was a result.
Lions FC 1, South Hobart 2 in Brisbane.
South Hobart became the first Tasmanian club to win an Australian Championship match.
A terrific achievement and one that deserves recognition.
But after yesterday's loss, South Hobart is fourth in its group again with two games left.
The competition isn't over. There are still points to win.
But what if South Hobart finishes fourth again?
I have no idea what the club spent on those players. I'm not suggesting any figure.
It may have been modest. There may have been arrangements that made the recruits affordable.
But there was an investment of some kind.
And if the club finishes in the same position, what did that investment return?
One more win so far. And what a win it was.
What about the gate?
In 2025, three home games at D'Arcy Street drew 1,348, 929 and 825.
This year's first home game, against Preston Lions, drew 705.
That was only a fortnight after the historic win in Brisbane.
I'm still waiting on the figure for yesterday's game. I'll add it when I have it.
It's early days. The opponents were different and the 2025 games had the novelty of a brand new competition.
But so far the recruits haven't brought more people through the gate.
I don't have the answer. I'm still thinking it through.
But if the final position doesn't change and the crowds don't grow, what does the money buy?
And what is one win in Brisbane worth to a club with another 39 teams?
Winning doesn't necessarily pay the bills
Soccernomics makes an interesting distinction between wages and transfers.
In English football, the clubs that paid the highest wages almost always finished highest. Wages explained more than 90 per cent of where clubs finished.
Transfer fees were a different story.
The authors looked at what each club spent buying players, minus what it earned selling them.
That figure explained only 16 per cent of where clubs finished.
Big buyers didn't do much better than clubs that sold their players on.
In other words, steady investment over years pays off far more reliably than one-off buys.
That's English football, with sums of money Tasmanian clubs will never see.
But the principle is worth thinking about. A player recruited for six national games looks a lot more like a one-off buy than a long-term investment.
There's also a difference between spending to improve your chances and getting a financial return on that spending.
Take Tasmania's NPL.
Clubs pay players and coaches, travel the state and compete all season.
The prize money for winning is welcome.
But it doesn't come close to covering the cost of a competitive NPL squad.
So the case for spending more on players can't simply be that the club might win the premiership.
It has to be about something else.
Prestige. Sponsors. Supporters. Qualifying for national competitions.
Those things have value.
But how much? And is it worth the extra spending?
I wonder how many clubs actually sit down and work that out.
Not just what they spent, but what they got back.
What about the players we already have?
Tasmania has only so many footballers.
Bringing in better players from elsewhere can improve a team in the short term.
Sometimes that's absolutely worthwhile.
A good recruit can lift standards, bring experience and help the younger players around them.
Tasmanian football has had some excellent interstate and overseas players over the years. I wouldn't dismiss their contribution for a moment.
But there's a difference between a recruit who becomes part of the club for several seasons and someone brought in for a short national campaign.
One helps build a club.
The other is mainly an investment in immediate results.
If that investment doesn't change the outcome, was it worth it?
Especially if it costs an existing player their place, their confidence or their reason to come back next season.
What if the money had gone into coaching, equipment or the club's younger players instead?
Would that give a better return over five years?
We can't know without the figures.
But it's a question worth asking.
A little philosophy with the football
Back to Edward de Bono.
He encouraged people to look past the obvious answer to a problem.
Here, the obvious answer is that Tasmania needs better players to compete nationally, so we go and find them somewhere else.
But turn the question around.
Instead of asking how we buy better players, why not ask how we produce more of them?
And Sartre?
He placed great weight on freedom and responsibility.
We can't choose Tasmania's population. We can't conjure up the budgets of the big mainland clubs.
But we can choose what we do with what we have.
Chase short-term success, or build something that produces better footballers over many years.
Of course we can try to do both.
The question is whether we can afford to.
Ned will probably tell me I've oversimplified Sartre.
He'd be right.
But I reckon de Bono would at least approve of asking a different question.
What are we trying to achieve?
What should success look like for a Tasmanian football club?
Winning the NPL?
Competing nationally?
Producing players who can go on to higher levels?
Keeping young people in football?
Building a club that can pay its way?
Ideally, all of the above.
But there are only so many dollars to go around.
South Hobart has another 39 teams beyond its senior men.
Hundreds of players, coaches, volunteers and families.
The club's responsibilities go well beyond 11 players on a Saturday afternoon.
That's not unique to South Hobart. Every club has to balance the ambitions of its senior team against the needs of everyone else.
I'm not suggesting clubs shouldn't try to win. Of course they should.
And I'm certainly not saying we should give up on national competitions because Tasmania is small.
That would be rather depressing.
A strong senior side can lift a whole club. It inspires juniors, attracts sponsors and gives players something to aim for.
But I do wonder whether we sometimes spend money trying to overcome disadvantages built into the structure of Australian football.
And whether that money could sometimes do more elsewhere.
Back to Ned
So where have I landed?
Ned's spreadsheet helps explain why Tasmania finds national competition so hard.
Soccernomics explains some of the reasons behind it.
Population matters. Wealth matters. Experience matters.
Money spent on players can improve performance too.
But none of it decides a particular game.
South Hobart proved that in Brisbane.
Ned's spreadsheet tells us the odds.
The harder question is what we should pay to change them.
If spending on recruits brings lasting success, raises standards and builds a stronger club, it may well be money well spent.
If it buys one memorable win and leaves us roughly where we started, perhaps there was a better use for it.
Particularly in a state with so few footballers.
The Australian Championship isn't over. There's still football to be played.
Perhaps South Hobart will make my questions redundant.
I'd be delighted.
Either way, I'll keep watching.
Ned can keep working on the odds.
I'll keep asking what they cost.