Press Release Speak. Football Tasmania Edition.

Clearer. Streamlined. Sustainable. Genuine. And a little bit of signalling.

Now, you're all sensible football people. You can read Football Tasmania's media release for yourselves.

But in case you haven't, I'll give you the gist.

With a little translation.

Because the most interesting part of a press release isn't always the information.

It's how the organisation wants you to feel about it.

Football's love affair with adjectives

Not long ago, in Surprise, Surprise. Or Perhaps Not., I wrote about Tasmania's annual game of coaching musical chairs and the language clubs use to announce it.

An exciting new chapter. A fresh challenge. Taking the club to the next level.

Blah, blah, blah.

It seems football's love affair with adjectives doesn't stop at coaching announcements.

Football Tasmania's latest release gives us a splendid collection.

Clearer. Streamlined. Simpler. Sustainable. Accessible. Genuine. Strengthening. Opportunities.

Golly.

They're all lovely words. Nobody is going to demand more complicated competitions and fewer opportunities for players.

But the words don't just tell us what's happening.

They tell us to feel good about it.

What it says. What it means.

So let's look at what's actually changing.

This is the men's structure. The women's league has already had its turn at being renamed.

What it says: Championship 1 will be discontinued, with teams transitioning into the newly named League 1 competitions.

What it means: Championship 1 is gone. Those teams now play in League 1.

What it says: The restructure removes the requirement for Championship clubs to also field a Championship 1 team.

What it means: If you're in the Championship you no longer have to field a second team. You can if you want to.

This one I like.

If a club is struggling for numbers, why should it be forced to scrape together another team just to stay in the Championship?

That's a practical change that could make a real difference.

What it says: Below the Championships sit League 1 to League 4 South, and League 1 to League 3 in the North and North West.

What it means: The lower divisions will be organised under the League 1, League 2 and subsequent division names. More on that shortly.

What it says: The top team in each league goes up and the bottom team goes down, but there is no automatic promotion or relegation between League 1 and Championship.

What it means: Exactly that. And to be fair, FT spells it out plainly.

Nothing hidden there.

Clearer for whom?

FT tells us the restructure creates a:

"clearer and more streamlined competition structure across the state."

Lovely.

But clearer for whom?

The club president working out which competition to nominate teams in?

The volunteer who has to get across another set of regulations?

Or the people at Football Tasmania who administer the competitions?

Perhaps all three. That would be wonderful.

Then there's sustainable. A favourite word in football administration.

I'm all for it. Particularly if it means clubs can afford to operate and volunteers aren't driven to distraction.

But changing the names and the structure doesn't automatically make anything sustainable.

Football isn't made sustainable by a media release.

It's made sustainable by the people who turn up every week and keep the bloody thing running.

Social football. What's in a name?

One change I particularly like is the move from social football to League 1, League 2 and so on.

I've always found social football an odd description.

A few mates having a kick around on a Sunday? A few beers afterwards? Nobody fussed about the result?

Try telling that to some of the players in those leagues.

They want to win. They have rivalries. They take their football every bit as seriously as anyone in the higher divisions.

And imagine being 19, finished with youth football and wanting to keep playing competitively.

"Congratulations. You're now a social footballer."

Golly. At 19. Practically ready for the retirement village.

Labels matter. If a proper league name keeps even a few more young people in the game, everybody wins.

I don't envy the poor Competitions Manager who has to decide which teams go where, though.

Every club will have an opinion about where it belongs.

Another round of musical chairs. This time for divisions.

Some will believe they deserve to be higher. Others will be quite happy where they are, thank you very much.

FT says it will work with clubs to finalise entries ahead of 2027.

So the arguments haven't even started yet.

When they do, I suspect the outrage will be palpable.

Good luck with that one.

Genuine promotion and relegation

Now here's a phrase I enjoyed.

FT wants to introduce a:

"genuine promotion and relegation system through our regional leagues."

Genuine.

As opposed to what? Pretend promotion and relegation?

Then we get this little gem. It will give clubs and players:

"something to compete for throughout the season."

Really?

What on earth have they been doing all these years?

I thought they were competing for premierships, bragging rights and the considerable satisfaction of beating the club down the road.

Promotion and relegation adds another incentive and that's a good thing.

But in trying to make a change sound wonderful, the language manages to diminish what was already there.

Have the Chosen Ones spoken?

Towards the end of the release we learn the changes followed discussions through FT's Competitions Working Group.

Ah. The working group.

Could these be the all-seeing Chosen Ones I wrote about previously? Those entrusted with pondering the future of Tasmanian football while the rest of us waited for the white smoke?

I don't know. The release doesn't say who was on it.

I do hope someone remembered the biscuits.

Seriously though, a Competitions Working Group is a sensible idea. These decisions need people who understand how competitions work.

But I'd be interested to know who was represented. Clubs from the different divisions? The people who enter teams, find volunteers and pay the bills?

The release tells us there were discussions. It doesn't tell us who took part or how.

Mentioning a working group lends an announcement a reassuring air of collective wisdom.

And perhaps the wisdom was considerable.

I'd just like to know whose wisdom it was.

And while we're talking about whose voices are heard, my State of Tasmanian Football survey is still open.

If you have views about how our game is being run, I'd love to hear them.

Selling the dream

During an Asian Football Confederation course I attended, we talked about something called signalling.

It's about sending messages about what you're doing, what you intend to do or how you'd like people to interpret it.

Remember when FIFA floated a World Cup every two years? Then, once the howls started, explained it was only studying whether it was feasible?

Oh, right. Just having a look then.

So what is FT signalling here?

I reckon it goes something like this.

Look at us. We're making changes. We're listening. We're making life easier for volunteers. And don't worry, we've discussed it with people.

Nobody ever announces they've had a bit of a fiddle with the competitions and they're hoping it works.

It's always strengthening football at all levels. Sustainable into the future.

Which sounds reassuring. Though surely the future is where sustainability is supposed to happen.

Imagine a press release with no adjectives.

"We've scrapped Championship 1. Clubs no longer have to field two teams. There's promotion and relegation in the regional leagues. We'll see how it goes."

Not terribly exciting.

But refreshingly clear.

Am I being unfair?

Possibly.

FT has made some sensible decisions.

Removing a compulsory second team is welcome. Giving the lower divisions a proper identity is welcome. Promotion and relegation could be a worthwhile addition.

I hope it works.

But the real test is what happens when the football starts.

Will more players stay in the game? Will clubs find it easier to field teams? Will the load on volunteers actually get lighter?

If the answer is yes, I'll happily give Football Tasmania the credit.

A press release tells us what an organisation wants us to know.

The adjectives tell us how it wants us to feel.

The football season will tell us whether any of it worked.

Previous
Previous

Football Governance 101: What Did Anter Isaac Actually Say?

Next
Next

I Failed Maths, But I Understand the Offside Rule